The Moral Blindness of the Modern “Reformed”
A demonic persona from Lord of the Rings
Just before Halloween in 2026 I had a Facebook conversation with one of our burgeoning number of worldling (un) “Reformed”, in which horror fiction was being advocated as both biblically lawful, and profitable, by a relatively well-known “Theonomist” type, Dan Brannan. Mr. Brannan was sharing a post by another of like persuasion, John Moody, who was making a grand apologetic just before Halloween for the lawfulness of such literature. Mr. Brannan was reposting and adding his “two cents worth”, likewise forwarding the same advocacy. While much of what Mr. Brannan says on many other subjects is of considerable value and provides edifying insight, yet he is sadly just another one of our modern Reformed Moral Relativists when it comes to bearing any resemblance to the Reformed tradition he imagines he embraces and represents. But Mr. Brannan is not unique in such advocacy. Were it otherwise, this entire article would be unnecessary. The infection is general. The modern worldling contingent is legion, and its not just that they are blind to it, but that they remain blind to it in the face of the most obvious of contradictions out of an untinctured commitment to advance a novel perversion of Christian ethics among the people of God.
To this peculiar specie of modern blindness I made the following reply:
“The modern pseudo-Reformed obsession with perverse entertainment, and its commitment to its defense paralleling any jealousy for the gospel, is about as Reformed as the mass. But nothing will assuage this iron clutch upon vice. Except of course final judgment.”
And yes, that set things off.
The fundamental device levied in the defense of this degeneracy was the expected good-witch/bad-witch paradigm, so common in the modern (un)Reformed worldling’s desperate apologetic to validate such perversities. There is good satanic fiction to be embraced, and of course that very bad satanic fiction to be avoided. Think: “Wizard of Oz” —good-witch, bad-witch paradigm. I’m old enough to remember Harry Potter being eviscerated by any and every evangelical this side of Robert Schuller. But then there was one lone voice, and then two, and then a dozen, and so on. Now Potter is really hip. So hip, that one will find himself eviscerated if he doesn’t think Harry Potter is a perfectly wholesome example of fiction within certain confessions of backsliders, and perhaps even among professing Christians in general. It’s the next logical step after Lord of the Rings.
Many will point out that an explicit Christian message is claimed for Lord of the Rings by it’s author, J. R. Tolkien. But unless he had made such a confession, you’d never know it otherwise, as there is zero copy in the narrative of the book itself to indicate it. But accepting that Christian allegory was thus intended what does that leave us with, but a Jesus who practices magic, overcomes with spells, and overcomes but other witchy ones with better magic. Lewis is exactly the same. Aslan, who represents Jesus, is repeatedly depicted as practicing magic, but just better magic. After Aslan is resurrected from the Stone Table, he explains to Susan and Lucy why the Witch’s power failed to keep him. He tells them: “It means… that though the Witch knew the Deep Magic, there is a magic deeper still which she did not know. Her knowledge goes back only to the dawn of time. But if she could have looked a little further back, into the stillness and the darkness before Time dawned, she would have read a different incantation.” Show me the person who is OK with that, and I’ll show you an unregenerate professing Christian, or one compromised in his walk to the point of spiritual blindness, for who else could accept such blasphemy against God as normative? Jesus just had better magic that the witch didn’t know about? That’s why Satan didn’t prevent the resurrection, eh? It would appear that the only “magic” here is that played upon the Christian to get him thinking such parallels are not just acceptable but excellent literature. It would appear that just saying the word “allegory” affords some magic spell of blindness that effectually dismisses all critique in the Christian’s discernment. Allegory can be good or evil, and making a “Jesus” who overcomes evil by better incantations is not only evil its grossly evil, such that one wonders with pain why it fails to engage the jealousy of saints to despise it utterly.
That there is no offense, but only defense; no outrage but only advocacy, of such heinous blasphemy is perhaps as indicative of the horrific condition of modern Christendom as any other factor that might be cited. Andy Stanley’s advocacy of faggotry is pure innocence compared to representing the thrice holy God of the bible as one who practices witchcraft. What could make the modern church so utterly and perfectly indifferent to such an outrage? What watchmen are left when this is not just practiced by degenerate worldlings sneaking into the church, but where masses of Christians are herded into the acceptance and defense of such arrant blasphemies by their thus blind and degenerate ministers?
Mr. Brannan eventually posted a link to a youtube video in this conversation which attempts to defend most of your horror films and literature of the last 50 or so years, and thus we have a concrete idea of exactly what he is defending when he makes such parallels. Mr. Brannan’s position is that if you condemn such examples of demonic cinema or literature its the moral equivalent of condemning Bunyan’s Pilgrims Progress or Holy War, because they both have horror. But they don’t, and the attempt to equate them is exactly the point of extreme folly and moral blindness being exposed and reproved. Even Foxe’s Book of Martyrs was mentioned as a book that would be condemned if you were legalistic enough to condemn Dracula films, according to Mr. Brannan. And he even went beyond this and said that the bible itself was horror literature. Mr. Brannan: “The immediate trouble with declaring horror stories categorically unchristian is that the bible itself has horror woven all through it. And Christian literature has always followed suit.” Christian literature has always followed suit. … you knew that right? Christian literature has always had that element of Bella Lugosi in it, because of the bible’s example. That is commitment to a perverse ideal to the point of being demented.
Let the following sample of our dialogue suffice:
“Dan Brannan
Charles L. Church Christian’s journey through the Valley of the Shadow of Death is horrifying. Absolutely. So is his battle with Apollyon. As is his death sentence in Doubting Castle, and the martyrdom of his companion in Vanity Faire. Much horror thoughout.
Charles L. Church
Dan Brannan Sir …. it’s allegorical. We don’t read those accounts (I’ve read it 2-3x) and even remotely think of the thing itself unless blinded to the whole point. We see ourselves beset by sin and temptation and being overwhelmed and then prevailing etc Or being beaten daily in doubting castle … we see how we think we possess our vision of hope but that it can be darkened by sin giving Satan an advantage that only God can (and does) deliver us from. None of it means what is merely incidentally depicted and its a man as rare as blind who fails to perceive the allegory and in that case is abusing the entire purpose of the book. Modern horror either literature or cinema intends no such allegory but means only what is depicted. Narnia you say? OK, and no one calls it horror either on account of such content for the same reason. It’s explicit allegory. Lewis’ work should be rejected for bad theology, not horror. Narnia ends in universalism and Lewis was a heretic. (See John Robbin’s critique at Trinity Foundation) Puritans might sparsely mention grotesque Greek mythology but that’s hardly a sanction. I might say “no soup for you!” but I’ve neither watched nor would advocate for Seinfeld. The truth is that any advocacy of any modern horror literature or cinema is a thing soundly condemned in Reformed literature. And that should make you pause.
Dan Brannan
Charles L. Church Yes, everyone knows The Pilgrim’s Progress is an allegory. But that doesn’t change the matter one iota and I daresay you know it. To pretend as if you cannot see Bunyan strongly (and rightly) favored elements of horror in depicting the spiritual forces of evil is just absurd.
To say you’ve read it multiple times “without even remotely thinking of the thing itself” means you haven’t actually read it, only held it and made up a different story in your head. Or that you’re being dishonest with me. Or maybe even with yourself.
Charles L. Church
Dan Brannan I dare say that only a blinded unbeliever or a child has ever read Pilgrim’s Progress and failed to perceive the allegorical meaning of its narrative. No one reads of doubting castle and thinks of a man being beaten or eaten by a giant, or if one does he does so because he’s spiritually blind, a child, or is perhaps desperate to support an untenable parallel. ![]()
You are advocating for such a bizarre viewpoint simply because walking it back is your only other alternative. You take your spiritual blindness for vision, and vision for spiritual blindness. But water is wet and the sky is blue, Mr. Brannan, and pilgrims Progress is only a horror story to a blind man.” {This phrase had been used by Mr. Brannan earlier, as for how obvious it was that horror literature was godly, and this is but replying in kind}
And my reader can plainly see that condemning a Dracula movie or reading Harry Potter is the equivalent of condemning Pilgrim’s Progress right? Well no. No one thinks that unless they have abused their conscience so long as to see no difference between God and Satan. Even in those examples of devilish literature and cinema that pretend to represent some remote Christian truths, yet look at them! Spell-casting sorcerers and warlocks are the heroes —and this is depicted as the same thing as God’s people being the victors, who overcome by scripture and faith, and where Jesus Christ is the hero who overcomes because infinitely powerful, wise, sovereign and merciful. This is the same thing as sorcerers overcoming by witchcraft, and spell-casting? What Christian would see a parallel in that?
But any of the similitudes from Bunyan are not only purely allegorical of great Christian truths, there is no one who reads of Giant Despair beating Christian and thinks it a mere gratuitous scene of dark magic or or a gratuitous blood & guts scene, but of the erring Christian having left the right path, and being allowed of divine providence to learn from his error. Excepting the child, illiterate, or perhaps someone trying to warrant their penchant for darkness, literally no one finds a horror theme in the open similitude of the Pilgrim’s Progress but Christian gospel truth. But apparently to some, those are the same thing. For so dark is the mind of this individual that it’s unthinkable that I would be contemplating of the pain of losing my way when reading about bypath meadow rather than the imagery representing it, so much so that he basically calls me a liar and thinks I’ve never read it. He first acknowledges its pure allegory, and then can’t believe that anyone took it as such. And yet when men see witches and warlocks casting spells upon one another in Potter, or Gandalf reciting incantations to stay the assault of Balrog, they are not thinking of Jesus and his victory over Satan, and if they are they are filled with blasphemies that have made Jesus into one practicing witchcraft.
If such productions are defended as representing some spiritual truth, then simply mark the contrast of the mere gratuitous demonism that is pleased to represent both God and Satan as practicing the same craft, one simply being better at it. So soon as an allegory is claimed in all such idolatrous novels, from Lord of the Rings, Narnia, or whatever, is the depiction of God as one who practices witchcraft. And that is a doctrine of devils. If your ok with that, you need pastoral care and the aid of the saint’s admonitions and prayers in a most urgent degree. But all you are likely to find is a brazen condemnation of Christianity should you awaken to what is being sold in such a devilish paradigm of entertainment.
And we are to believe that such blasphemy is exactly what we find in Bunyan’s Pilgrim Progress. All the same thing, we’re told, yes? That’s what you always thought before, right? Jesus as Jesus vs. Jesus as Warlock? Same thing? Who would not concede the religious equality of the parallel? Any sane Christian not given over to a reprobate mind, that is who. Why the bible itself is a book of horror Mr. Brannan assures us, as though the the one justifies the other, and prohibiting one, prohibits the other. The Holy Scriptures are such a parallel to LOTR, Narnia & Harry Potter, you can know for sure that if you condemn one of these you’ve condemned the bible! What blindness from hell makes any man make such claims? Do Christianity and Satanism differ only in degree of adeptitude in satanic power? How indescribably wicked. Such persons may understand LOTR or Harry Potter, or who knows what else, but they most assuredly know not a thing about the bible, nor apparently of Pilgrim’s Progress either.
So as such persons love to pretend to be from the Reformed tradition, I provided many witnesses from those these ostensibly respect, vainly imagining that English was not a second language. However, after providing the following citations I was assured that I was woefully deceived to imagine that such Reformed authors reproved or forbade horror novels, & etc. I post these references here just to show how psychotic and delusional the commitment to worldling religion has become in that church that was once equaled by none for its standards of personal holiness. The quotes provided:
*******
Samuel Willard (1640–1707)
Willard, a influential Boston pastor and vice-president of Harvard, preached extensively on how light entertainment around demonic or magical themes breaks down spiritual defenses. In his work A Complete Body of Divinity, he wrote:
“The mind of man is like a mill; what you pour into it, it will grind. If you pour in holy truths, it grinds out holy affections. But if you pour in foolish, light, and dark fictions—tales of magic, witches, and demonic power—it will grind out nothing but vanity, dark thoughts, and a secret liking for things that God hath forbidden.”
John Owen (1616–1683) — Leading Puritan Theologian & Vice-Chancellor of Oxford
In A Treatise of the Dominion of Sin and Grace, Owen explained how reading light or sensational fictions allows sin to rule over the imagination before it ever manifests in outward actions:
“Sin may exercise its rule in the mind, fancy, and imagination… The first way whereby sin coins its motions into acts is by the imagination. When men fill their minds with foolish fictions, ungodly fables, or corrupt stories, they give Satan the steering of their thoughts. Though no outward crime be committed, the soul is secretly polluted and made unfit for communion with God.”
In The Grace and Duty of Being Spiritually Minded, Owen added:
“Vain imaginations, once raised by foolish or dark books, are like dust in a room; though the storm pass, the dust settles upon everything in the soul.”
Philip Doddridge (1702–1751) — 18th-Century Independent Calvinist Pastor
In his renowned work The Rise and Progress of Religion in the Soul (1745), Doddridge dedicated sections to advising young people on what they should read, directly warning against novels and “dark” or romanticized tales:
“Beware of those books which serve only to amuse the imagination while they starve the soul… Romances, plays, and foolish fables of marvels and dark wonders are the ruin of thousands. They give a false and unnatural representation of life, make real duties seem dull and insipid, and insensibly prepare the mind for the insinuations of the Tempter.”
Matthew Henry (1662–1714) — Nonconformist Calvinist Commentator
Commenting on 1 Timothy 4:7 (“Refuse profane and old wives’ fables”):
“Frivolous tales, dark superstitions, and foolish stories of ghosts and wonders are unfit for a Christian’s ear, much more his library. They silly the mind and take off the edge of spiritual desire.”
Increase Mather (1639–1723) Early American Puritan
In An Essay for the Recording of Illustrious Providences (1684) (often called Remarkable Providences), Increase Mather (Cotton Mather’s father and President of Harvard) argued against popular tales, chapbooks, and street literature featuring wizards, ghouls, and specters:
“To read or tell foolish, scary stories of specters, goblins, and dark enchantments serves only to corrupt the imagination… The Devil delights to be talked of and read about in foolish fables; for by them he either frightens men into slavish, superstitious fear, or else lulls them into a scoffing, profane mind where they treat the spiritual world as a mere game.”
William Perkins (1558–1602)
In A Discourse of the Damned Art of Witchcraft, Perkins—one of the foundational theologians of Puritanism—addressed the subtle ways people engage with witchcraft without becoming practicing witches. He specifically condemned curiosity about the dark arts through literature, fables, and fortune-telling guides:
“It is a sin not only to practice witchcraft, but to maintain a curious and delighting itch after the knowledge of it… To read, retain, or delight in books, charms, or stories of magical arts is an unlawful curiosity. It is to drink of the Devil’s cup in secret while professing to be a servant of Christ.”
Perkins argued that reading about magical feats or demonic pacts for entertainment violates the First and Second Commandments because it treats the dark, forbidden world as a source of pleasure or amusement rather than an abomination.
Cotton Mather (1663–1728)
Mather—who wrote extensively during the Salem crisis—was acutely concerned about how curiosity about witchcraft spread through books and tales, especially among young people. In Memorable Providences (1689) and Wonders of the Invisible World (1693), he noted that reading “foolish” or “wretched” books on magic served as the precursor to spiritual affliction:
“There are books of sorcery, play-books, and foolish fables which serve as the Devil’s library… When young persons feed their minds upon stories of magic, foolish divinations, and spectral wonders, they do but tempt the Devil to tempt them. They make themselves a fit dwelling for unclean spirits by painting their imaginations with his imagery.”
Richard Baxter (1615–1691)
Baxter explicitly addressed those who thought reading about magic, sorcery, or witches in stories was harmless fun or merely entertaining. In A Christian Directory (1673), he treats reading about “witchcraft, sorcery, and foolish wonders” in light books as a psychological trap set by Satan:
“Beware of reading foolish tales of witches, hobgoblins, wizards, and apparitions… These do fill the mind with vain, dark, and superstitious imaginations, and leave a secret poison in the fancy. Though you think you only read them for delight, they insensibly unhinge the heart from God and dispose it to Satanic delusions.”
He further adds regarding “harmless” interest in supernatural fictions:
“Satan enters the heart oftenest through the window of a corrupted imagination. He that reads books of magic, strange wonders, and dark fables for pleasure is taking fuel to the devil’s fire.”
There is another citation that I omitted, and presented as my own words (in modernized form) to see if Mr. Brannan would cavil at it, not realizing it was one of those he needed to pretend he agreed with. He didn’t take the bait. That was a quote from Reformed English clergyman William Romaine, (1714–1795).
William Romaine
“What a perversion of the intellect, which God gave for the contemplation of His eternal truth, to spend precious days and nights poring over the inventions of men—tales of witches, enchantments, and imaginary heroes. These things are calculated to feed the corrupt passions of the old man, to make the spiritual life appear dull, and to substitute a false, emotional wonder for the true fear of God.”
— Discourses on the Walk of Faith
Context: Romaine explicitly flagged tales involving witchcraft, enchantment, and human invention as antithetical to spiritual maturity, arguing they breed a counterfeit sense of wonder that competes with the majesty of God.
*******
To this rendering of actual Reformed opinion I was given the following reply from Mr. Brannan:
“All great quotes. But I’m afraid you understand them no better than you understand my expressed position. Or, for that matter, your own. I don’t want to berate you, Chuck. I’d rather encourage you to slow down and think about the positions you advocate before you wind up blasting your own feet off.”
And such citations from the actual-Reformed plainly don’t reprove witchy novels, right? It was obvious these revered witnesses weren’t doing that, right? They thought such productions as wholly parallel of the bible, right? The person who thinks these actually Reformed citations reprove witchy novels plainly doesn’t understand anything about this subject, right? With the growing number of blind worldlings proliferating in Christendom, maybe not. But I would hope that there are yet a great many within God’s outward Kingdom that have been saved from the judicial blindness that sees a parallel in such consummate antipodes, and for whom English is not a second language, be their prejudices what they may.
Reader, please candidly ask yourself why it is that such persons can not just candidly declare the obvious….. “yeah, obviously I dissent from these authors and think they’re ignorant like you”? Don’t you see it reader? It’s because they’re pretending to be the heirs apparent to these gospel confessors. They cannot allow themselves to admit the disparity or the whole cover is gone. The pretense is exposed. They hypocrisy and pharisaical posturing as the true descendants of the prophets is at an end. So they gnash their teeth, foam at the mouth and have seizures at the truths of the just, while posturing as their children. They gnash their teeth like Laud, because they are the children of Laud. They behave like the enemies of the Puritans because they ARE the enemies of the Puritans. They’re telling you they are children of Owen et. al. while foaming at the mouth at what these plainly taught, and thus indelibly mark themselves as the children of Pharisees: They build the sepulchres of the prophets, but their fathers killed them. They want to borrow only their repute and not their principles, which they utterly despise, and the hypocrisy of this posturing is unsearchable.
To this unintelligible response to such weighty examples of Reformed opinion, I made the following reply: “All your tinsel adherence to Reformed principle and theology is a pious fraud. You have not their Spirit, nor God’s, or such things would disgust you rather than engage your jealousy to defend.”
This immoral contagion has leached from the Doug Wilsons of the world down into the counsels of Reformed thought, until that church which was once the holiest of all, resembles the historical church it masquerades as being heirs to about as much as the Romish church resembles the apostles. Another Reformation is long overdue. The current brand of delusional enthusiasts truly believe that a worldly church will convert the world. They will “engage culture” with apologetics, as though God’s blessing followed worldlings who study theology, rather than that church filled with the Holy Spirit which rejoices in a salvation they know with power by the grace of the Holy Spirit, and have something that actually lives within that “knows the joyful sound”, worships, separates from evil, and which certainly lifts up a voice for every good thing in the earth, but first for the sovereign mercy that brought deliverance to themselves.
For any Christian that takes the command seriously, “Thy will be done on Earth as it is in Heaven”, or the declaration that God has called “all men everywhere” to repent”, the church is plainly called to herald submission of all of humanity to the dominion of Jesus Christ in every sphere of life. Less simply cannot be taking the bible seriously. However, these commands manifestly must start with ourselves, else they are commanding hypocrisy. Let God’s will be done IN ME as in Heaven, and may I find greater and greater measures of repentance first among “all men everywhere”. May the following words of Mr. Spurgeon encourage the tender of heart to all these things:
“The worldly Christian will not convert the world. If you are of the world, no doubt the world will love its own; but you cannot save the world. If you are dark, and belong to the kingdom of darkness, you cannot remove the darkness. If you march with the armies of the wicked one, you cannot defeat them.
“I believe that one reason why the church of God at this present moment has so little influence over the world is because the world has so much influence over the church. Nowadays we hear Nonconformists pleading that they may do this and they may do that— things which their Puritan forefathers would rather have died at the stake than have tolerated. They plead that they may live like worldlings, and my sad answer to them, when they crave for this liberty, is, “Do it if you dare. It may not do you much hurt, for you are so bad already. Your cravings show how rotten your hearts are.
“If you have a hungering after such dog’s meat, go, dogs, and eat the garbage. Worldly amusements are fit food for mere pretenders and hypocrites. If you were God’s children you would loathe the very thought of the world’s evil joys, and your question would not be, ‘How far may we be like the world?’ but your one cry would be, ‘How far can we get away from the world? How much can we come out from it?’” Your temptation would be rather to become sternly severe, and ultra-Puritanical in your separation from sin, in such a time as this, than to ask, ‘How can I make myself like other men, and act as they do?'”
“Come, ye children of God, you must stand out with your Lord outside the camp. Jesus calls to you to-day, and says, “Follow me.” Was Jesus found at the theatre? Did he frequent the sports of the racecourse? Was Jesus seen, think you, in any of the amusements of the Herodian court? Not he. He was “holy, harmless, undefiled, and separate from sinners.”
Mr. Brannan’s response is merely dismissive rather than didactic. This is all they feel they need to do, and all they really can do in the face of such citations. Rather than providing any substantiation of this alien advocacy I was first dismissed, and then given the following afore-mentioned apologetic from youtube, : https://youtu.be/ZHlwbykpYus The premise of this apologetic for horror film is that they are legitimate horror films which attempt to frame a contest between good and evil, and the good is always Christianity. And how were such contests qualified as “Christian”? Because someone held up a cross and the villain regressed. In other words, Romish superstition is the qualifying factor of such productions as being “Christian”. Thus if Romanism is Christianity, then yes, such productions are Christian. But Mr. Brannan seems to have forgotten that he was attempting to defend Reformed, not papist, theology and orthopraxy.
Some of the the horror productions that are explicitly validated in this way are listed as follows:
The Exorcism of Emily Rose
The Exorcism
Nefarious
The Conjuring
Rosemary’s Baby
The Omen
The Wicker Man
Dracula
The Rite
And these are the films being compared to Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress. Just what you think of when you think of Pilgrim’s Progress, right? Of course you do! Said no one ever. Unless they drank deeply of the Doug Wilson Kool-Aid. I simply provided the one reminder among many possible, that this was appealing to Romanism, not the Reformed for a defense, and that pretty much makes my point. But more to the point, it demonstrated beyond all controversy exactly what genre of productions Mr. Brannan has in mind by his advocacy, and it is altogether without any anchor or boundary whatever it would appear, other than that it must be Romish, as the video validates likely half the sick perverse media form of horror for the last 50 years. This, to Mr. Brannan, is all kin to the bible. And to Puritan allegory. May God cast this unclean spirit from His redeemed people, and remove the rest for their sake.
May this man, and all such men, be blessed of God to see that ancient way that they have forsaken, and to get back to marching in it. Amen.
Charles Church
Note: There are a great many who warrant the Harry Potter books based upon such arguments, and Mr. Brannan is certainly among them, considering this last video apologetic. But there is thankfully a division here, as there is no pretense to godliness whatever in the Potter novels, and there are still many that reject them. But that it doesn’t matter to most is but another witness to just how far we have forsaken the God of our fathers.